The 2022 Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) has fueled great growth in America’s renewable energy sector. As tax credits emerged, so did the prospect of lowering taxes and becoming a part of the battle for renewable energy. Two of the various tax credits on offer are the Investment Tax Credit (ITC) and the Production Tax Credit (PTC). The decision between the two is one that is absolutely critical, given that each possesses unique offerings and plays a vital role in affecting a project’s viability and rate of return.
A comprehensive analysis of ITC vs PTC can best help in deciding which one is more suitable for your energy deal strategy.
Understanding the Basics: ITC vs PTC
ITC offers a front-end reduction in federal income tax, expressed as a percentage of eligible capital expenditures of the project. For those projects that satisfy certain domestic content and labor conditions, the ITC may be as much as 30% of the overall cost of the project. Bonuses may add even more to this percentage, possibly up to 50%.
PTC provides a per-kilowatt-hour (kWh) credit for electricity produced by the project during a 10-year term. The initial rate is around 0.3 cents per kWh and may also qualify for bonus incentives under specific circumstances.
ITC vs PTC: Key Factors to Consider
Project Eligibility
Developers and manufacturers must understand eligibility before choosing the right option for ITC vs PTC.
-
ITC-eligible projects (clean energy developers)
-
-
- Solar energy
- Small wind turbines
- Fuel cells
- Geothermal systems
- Energy storage
- Combined heat and power systems
- Microturbines
-
-
ITC-eligible projects (manufacturing)
-
-
- Components required in clean energy production
- Energy storage and fuel cell systems
- Equipment required for electric grid modernization
- Low-carbon materials
- Clean or electric vehicles and components
- Equipment required for carbon capture
- Critical minerals processing and recycling
-
-
PTC-eligible projects (clean energy)
-
-
- Wind energy production
- Biomass facilities
- Wind energy facilities
- Renewable natural gas facilities
- Geothermal facilities
- Marine and hydrokinetic renewable energy facilities
- Qualified hydroelectric facilities
- Municipal solid waste facilities
-
-
PTC-eligible projects (manufacturing)
-
- Solar energy components
- Wind energy components
- Inverters
- Applicable critical minerals
- Qualifying battery components
Capital Expenditure
Those projects with greater initial costs, like those that require complicated installations or battery storage, might prefer the ITC because of the upfront tax relief it offers. On the other hand, projects with lower capital expenditure could prefer the PTC, taking advantage of the long-term production-based incentives.
Project Location and Bonuses
Further incentives are for renewable energy projects, depending on location and utilization of domestic materials. For instance, projects located in energy communities are eligible for a 10% bonus on either the Investment Tax Credit (ITC) or the Production Tax Credit (PTC). Likewise, projects that satisfy domestic content rules, like incorporating U.S.-made steel and iron, qualify for an additional 10% bonus. The bonuses can strongly impact the economic advantages of either credit, based on project details and qualifications.
Financing and Tax Appetite
The financing structure of the project and the tax appetite of investors are imperative. The immediate tax benefits in the case of the ITC can be preferable for investors with short-term tax liabilities. The PTC, with its extended benefit period, can be attractive to investors holding long-term tax liabilities.
Project Size
The ITC may be more helpful for larger utility-scale projects because of the significant upfront tax benefit, which can help to offset large initial investments. Smaller projects may prefer the PTC’s steady, long-term benefits.
Summing Up!
The decision of ITC vs PTC depends on various factors of the respective business or taxpayer. A proper study of the different structural, financial, and regulatory parameters can help make the decision easier and more effective. Regardless of the choice, understanding the requirements and ensuring eligibility is imperative.
